I am super proud of this guy…by far one of my more successful first attempts at a first time recipe. Which means if I can do it…get excited….you can too. I’ve been wanting to make a home made chicken pot pie since December. One of my room mates Emily made one for our house Christmas celebration which was super delicious and different then the other I’ve had. I found this recipe on allrecies.com and since all the recipes can be reviewed by users, this one promised to be a good one with 5 whopping stars!
This recipe was very much from scratch even down to the poultry seasoning and pie dough that I made. The recipe can be much easier if you decide to buy these things…of course. Instead of buying chicken breasts I bought a whole chicken
and decided to roast it in the oven.
I decided to make my own poultry seasoning and after looking at a few recipes and realizing that they all had marjoram and I’ve only ever misread marjoram, I decided I would have to improvise. I ended up using a teaspoon of celery salt, thyme, sage, ground nutmeg and garlic powder since that was the gist of all of them.
As for the chicken, I decided to go with the bundt pan method. If you haven’t already given this a try, I highly recommend it. The chicken can go in the center of the pan and of course all the drippings are caught in the bottom of the pan. Add some water to the bottom of the bundt pan, or beer, or apple juice.This time I did water, but I’ve done both beer and apple juice before for some extra flavor. I ended up putting a pie pan under the bundt pan since there is a whole in the center part of the bundt that will cause you some problems if you just put that in without it.
To prepare the bird, you grease him down with a little vegetable oil and then if you want to be just like me and keep you hands clean, use a shopping back to rub on your seasoning. Easy. I threw him in the oven for 20 min at 400 but I had to put some more time on the clock to make sure he was done. The quickest way to check is if you have a meat thermometer, however, you can cut into a thick part of the thigh and make sure the juices run clear. I think it may have take an additional 20 min or so. It might be wise to consult a recipe…but I wasn’t making roasted chicken for dinner :o) Oh wait…I took note, I did 400 degrees for 40 min then down to 375 for 20 min. I’m sure there is a happy medium, but that was my formula for done chicken!
While the bird was in the oven I started on the pie crust
. This recipe is awesome and I highly suggest making it for your sweet or savory pies. It couldn’t be easier. I have to say I was super skeptical on the consistency, but it worked out really well. The ingredients are basic: flour, sugar, salt, butter, and ice water. Grab your food processor for this job. The recipe says that you use anywhere from 6 to 8 teaspoons of ice water. When the dough comes together you can stop adding water…which is what I’m demonstrating below. I added 6 and it was just enough. The 2nd time I made the dough I used all 8…so consistency…is not my thing.
The recipe also says that if you want a flaky crust to knead the dough a bit before wrapping it up and putting it in the refrigerator. Note that this dough is going to be really hard when you pull it out of the refrigerator. It actually freaked me out when I pulled it out. I thought I was going to be terrible not to mention terribly hard to work with since it was so hard. Remember that a good portion of the dough is butter and that butter hardens when it’s in the refrigerator and also helps make the layers of the crust delicious. You’ll see pictures later, but a rolling pin will be your friend when it’s time to work it out.
So, I did all the roasting and pie crust making the night before I made the pot pie. I used this recipe
to make the pie with a few modifications…I excluded the peas…yuck…and used celery salt instead of celery seed and salt since, again, I didn’t have any. Honestly, who really keeps this on hand anyways?? So, my first picture below was a work of photographic art…yes, it’s the base of the celery stock that looks just like a rose. Pretty right?! Well…guess who had to pick out the onions because they didn’t read the recipe? This genius. Once again, read the recipe before you start working through it. It won’t hurt anything and save you more time in the long run. But I’m sure you already do this :( You’ll want to put your veggies and chicken (minus the onions) in a pot with water covering them and boil till tender. The onions will be a part of your gravy so those require a 2nd pot. Mistake number two for me is that not only did I forget to separate the onions, but I forgot to add the chicken in with the veggies and water…which is why they are absent. Learn from my mistakes friends….
To make the gravy, you will cook up your onions with the butter and when tender add your flour to thicken up the mix. Your chicken broth and milk will be poured into the mixture and the gravy will need some time to thicken over the heat. It will take about 10 minutes to get to the right consistency. My last picture shows what it looks like when it’s thickened a bit. Your spoon will help out with figuring that out.
As the gravy is thickening up pull your dough out start rolling it out and fitting it into the pan. Remember you’ll need a top and a bottom. I rolled out the bottom round which was impossible to make round, but you can use a knife to clean up the extra pieces and use the extra if you need to patch anything up. I ended up having extra dough so you could do fun things with the top if you wanted to:) I used the rolling pin to wrap the top piece. It was easier to roll it over the top of the pie once the veggies, chicken and gravy were poured in.
Now it’s time to assemble all hard work together…put your chicken veggie mixture in the pan and then pour in the gravy. You’ll have extra so don’t worry about trying to get it all in. I saved the gravy and used it to put on top of my sliced when I ate. Very tasty. Don’t forget to cut the extra dough off the edges and add a few wholes in the top to vent the steam from the pie.
You’ll put it in for 30 min at 425. Make sure to put your pie on a baking pan with sides like I did. Some of the gravy came out so this will save the bottom of your oven.
You will love this pot pie! I ate off of it for lunches and dinners for the next few days and was a very happy girl! And isn’t it pretty?! I used a little retro camera magic on the last photo, but it felt like a retro camera moment…I’m so proud.
Give this one a try friend…you won’t regret it!
Happy cooking and read your recipes before you cook!
Published by Jessica
I love to cook but let's be real..while this blog was meant to be about that...life happens...and quickly...when you get married and then pregnant 3 months later! While it would be dreamy to write all about novice cooking adventures I'm a novice at a lot more then cooking these days! So, you are officially welcome to the ramblings of this novice cook, wife, and mother!
View all posts by Jessica
2 Comments Add yours
That pot pie looks AMAZING!!! Chicken pot pie is one of my favorite things and yours looks like it came out of a magazine. Thanks for sharing. Love you friend!
Thank you Jamie! It was very rewarding to taste and see the final product :o) I vote we spend a day making this together…it would be way more fun!